Category Archives: film

Digging around inside nature’s giants

Credit: Windfall/Richard Taylor/Jones

A sperm whale’s penis has no bones. This allows its flexible member to penetrate a female sperm whale from any number of directions; a necessity when two multi-ton animals are trying to line up tab A with slot B in an unsteady ocean environment.

This and other interesting facts about sperm whales are the subject of the first episode of the documentary series Inside Nature’s Giants, which premiers in the U.S. on January 18th. Each of the series’ four episodes centers around the dissection of a large animal, which is used as a starting point to explore the animal’s biology. (A clever device, which I also used in this Scientific American video about jumbo squid.)

In episode one the ‘dissectee’ is a deceased sperm whale that has washed ashore on England’s east coast. Comparative anatomist Joy Reidenberg of Mount Sinai Hospital leads the dissection, sawing through blubber in one shot, enthusiastically explaining whale anatomy in the next. Of course, taking apart a sperm whale is no simple task and Reidenberg’s team must employ large carving knives, chainsaws and even construction equipment to peel back the successive layers of its anatomy. The goal, Reidenberg states, is to determine the cause of the whale”s death. It seems like the goal is more likely an interesting television show.

The gory spectacle of the whale dissection is punctuated by live footage of sperm whales and beautifully-rendered 3-D animations that give a clearer view of the whale’s internal anatomy minus the blood and guts. Occasionally, the film segues to scenes of evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins in London’s Natural History museum where he talks about the sperm whale’s evolution. These scenes felt a bit perfunctory (ie shoe-horned in) and were not very elucidating. Dawkins, while brilliant and charismatic as usual, isn’t a whale expert.

Future episodes will include the dissection of a python, great white shark, and lion, airing at 10 pm ET on PBS  January 25th, February 2nd, and February 8th respectively. The Inside Nature’s Giants series was produced by London-based Windfall Films in conjunction with Channel 4.

Share

Should broadcasters pay to protect the ‘stars’ of wildlife films?

A lion cub in Mana Pools National Park, Zimbabwe

A few weeks ago, I wrote about Discovery Channel’s reluctance to air the climate change episode of the Frozen Planet series–an episode they helped fund.  I asked that we label this act ‘unsustainable nature filmmaking’ because Discovery had failed to use its bully pulpit to protect the species that feature heavily in its films. An opinion piece in the journal Science this week, penned by Oxford geography professor Paul Jepson and colleagues, takes this argument one step further and asks that broadcasters like Discovery make direct monetary contributions to protect the ‘stars’ of wildlife films:

We ask whether it is time..[for] media corporations
producing and commissioning nature-based
programming…[to] adopt PES [payment for ecosystem services] principles.

For those unfamiliar with the concept of ‘payment for ecosystem services’, this is basically the idea that the many benefits provided to us by nature have a monetary value and that corporations profiting off of those services should give a percentage of profits back to conservation efforts.

read more »

Share

Discovery Channel and unsustainable nature filmmaking

On Tuesday the Daily Mail reported that the Discovery Channel will not broadcast the final episode of the popular Frozen Planet series in the U.S. Why? Because the show deals with climate change, an emerging threat to animals living in the subzero regions of our planet. Apparently, Discovery thinks this topic will offend the political sensibilities of some portion of its U.S. audience. How ridiculous. Climate change is a matter for science, not politics (or at least it should be). And even more ridiculous is that Discovery helped pay for the production of the very episode that they now refuse to air.

This got me thinking about the genre of so-called ‘blue-chip’ nature documentaries like Frozen Planet. These docs are built around charismatic megafauna engaged in life or death struggles. And honestly, some of these films are my favorites.  I mean, who can resist the pull of a full-grown male lion chasing down a hyena in a battle to the death? Who can say they don’t like Discovery’s ‘Shark Week’–just a little bit? read more »

Share